ТРИ ПИСМА ОЦА ГЕОРГИЈЕ ФЛОРОВСКОГ О ЕКУМЕНИЗМУ
Abstract
Протојереј Георгије Флоровски (1893-1979. г.) је најзначајнији
православни теолог 20. века. Поред предавања које је држао на неким од водећих
светских универзитета, такође је провео неколико деценија руководећи
међународним екуменском покретима. Овај чланак пружа преглед његових погледа
на изразито православни вид екуменизма и доноси три писма Флоровског на
екуменске теме, заједно са коментарима и белешкама. Прво писмо упућено Вилијаму
Николсу, објављено је на енглеском језику 1950. године, али друго и треће писмо,
упућена чувеном реформистичком теологу Томасу Ф. Торенсу 1953. и 1973. године,
су до сада необјављивана. Теме којих се дотиче у писмима укључују учење о Цркви,
немогућност међуопштење (интеркомуније), ”екуменизам у времену”, као и
кратако, али значајно упућивање на о. Сергија Булгакова, изразиту личност тзв.
руске религиозне ренесансе.
References
Baker M. “The Place of St. Irenaeus of Lyons in Historical and Dogmatic
Theology According to Thomas F. Torrance,” Participatio 2 (2010): 5-43. Чланак је
доступан и у електронском облику на следећој адреси:
http://www.tftorrance.org/journal/participatio_vol_2_2010.pdf (приступљено 5. децембра
2012. године)
Baker M., “The Eternal ‘Spirit of the Son’: Barth, Florovsky and Torrance on the
Filioque,” International Journal of Systematic Theology 12:4 (2010): 382-403.
Baker M., “Georges Florovsky -- Agony of Divine and Human Freedom,” in: Er.
Conradie (ed.), Creation and Salvation: A Medley of Recent Theologies, Berlin: LIT Verlag
2012, 29-35.
Baker, M. “Cosmological Contingency and Logical Necessity in G. Florovsky and
T. Torrance," Orthodox Theology and the Sciences, ed. Pavel Pavlov, Stoyan Tanev and
George Dragas (Columbia, MO: New Rome Press, forthcoming.
Baillie D. and J. Marsh (eds.), Intercommunion, London: Student Christian
Movement, 1952.
Chaplits A., Cosmic Redemption and the Incarnation of Christ in the Writings of
Georges V. Florovsky and Thomas F. Torrance, M.A. Thesis, Trinity International
University, 2006.
Choufrine A. M., “Sergei Bulgakov: His Life and His Reflection on It: A Case
Study for the Churching of Russian Intelligentsia,” in N. A. Pecherskaya (ed.), The
Emancipation of Russian Christianity, Lewiston - Queenston – Lampeter, 1995, 1-16.
Chrysostomos of Etna, “Protopresbyter Georges Florovsky,” Orthodox Tradition
11:2 (1994): 28-29.
Congar Yves M.-J., Chretiens Desunis. Principes d'un "oecumenisme" catholique.
Unam Sanctam 1, Paris: Cerf, 1937.
Florovsky, G., “The Antinomies of Ecumenical Quest,” у; Georges Florovsky
Papers, Box 5, Folder 1; Department of Rare Books and Special Collections, Princeton
University Library.
Florovskij, G.V., “Náboženská zkušenost a filiofické vyznání,” Ruch filosoficky,
3:3:9-10 (1923), 298-306. Рад је објављен и на српском: Г. В. Флоровски, “Религиозно
искуство и филосовско исповедање”, Хришћански живот, 3:3 (1924): 105-118.
Florovsky G., “L’idée de la création dans la philosophie chrétienne,” Logos:
Revue Internationale de la Synthèse Orthodoxe 1 (1928): 3-30;
Флоровский Г. В., “Тварь и тварность,” Православная мысль 1 (1928), 176-212.
Florovsky, G., “The Limits of the Church,” Church Quarterly Review 117:233
(1933): 117-31.
Florovsky, G., “A Visit to Anglican Theological Colleges,” Journal of the
Fellowship of St. Alban and St. Sergius 21 (Sept 1933): 38-40.
Florovsky, G., “The Need for Patience,” Christendom 2:4 (1937): 556–559.
Florovsky, G., “The Idea of Creation in Christian Philosophy,” Eastern Churches
Quarterly 8:2 (1949): 53-77.
Florovsky, G., “The Legacy and the Task of Orthodox Theology,” Anglican
Theological Review 31:2 (1949): 65-71
Florovsky, G., “Une vue sur l’Assemblée d’Amsterdam,” Irénikon, 22.1 (1949): 5-25.
Florovsky, G., “Intercommunion: An Inter-‘Catholic’ Discussion,” The Student
World 43:2 (1950): 169-171.
Florovsky G., “The Doctrine of the Church and the Ecumenical Problem”, The
Ecumenical Review, 2:2 (Winter 1950): 152–161.
Florovsky, G., “Confessional Loyalty in the Ecumenical Movement,” The Student
World 53:1 (1950), 59-70.
Florovsky, G., “The Eastern Orthodox Church and the Ecumenical Movement,”
Theology Today, 7:1 (1950): 68-79.
Florovsky, G., “The Challenge of Disunity,” St Vladimir's Seminary Quarterly
3:1-2 (1954): 31-36.
Florovsky, G., “The Orthodox Churches and The Ecumenical Movement Prior to
1910,” in R. Rouse and S. C. Neill (eds.), A History of the Ecumenical Movement, 1517-
1948, Philadelphia: The Westminster Press 1954: 171-215.
Florovsky, G., “The Orthodox Church and the World Council of Churches,” St
Vladimir's Seminary Quarterly 2:4 (1954): 11-18, 12.
Florovsky, G., ”The Challenge of Disunity”, Union Seminary Quarterly Review
10:1 (Nov 1954): 15-20.
Florovsky, G., “The Predicament of the Christian Historian,” in: Walter Leibrecht
(ed.), Religion and Culture: Essays in Honor of Paul Tillich, New York: Harper &
Brothers, 1959: 140-166, 359-362.
Florovsky, G., “The Ethos of the Orthodox Church,” Ecumenical Review 12:2
(1960): 183-198.
Florovsky, G., “Primitive Tradition and the Traditions,” in W. S. Morris (ed.), The
Unity We Seek, Toronto: Ryerson Press, 1962: 28-38.
Florovsky, G., “Obedience and Witness,” in: R. Mackie and C. West (eds), The
Sufficiency of God: Essays in Honor of W. A. Visser’t Hooft, London: Student Christian
Movement Press, 1963: 58-70.
Florovsky, G., “The Problem of Ecumenical Encounter,” in E. J. B. Fry and A. H.
Armstrong (eds.), Re-Discovering Eastern Christendom, London: Darton, Longman &
Todd, 1963: 63-76.
Florovsky, G., “Interview with Georges Florovsky,” Concern 3:4 (Fall 1968): 9-
12, 27.
Florovsky, G., “Interview with Father G. Florovsky,” The Third Hour 9 (1970):
31-38.
Florovsky, G., Ways of Russian Theology, vol. II, Belmont, Mass.: Nordland Pub.
1987.
Fraser B., The Study of Religion in British Columbia, Waterloo, Ontario: Wilfrid
Laurier University Press 1995.
Gallaher B., “Bulgakov and intercommunion,” Sobornost 24:2 (2002): 9-28.
Irvine C., Worship, Church and Society: An Exposition of the Work of Arthur
Gabriel Hebert, Norwich: Canterbury Press, 1993.
Neiman. D and M. Schatkin (eds.), The Heritage of the Early Church: Essays in
Honor of George Florovsky, (Orientalia Christiana Analecta 195), Rome: Pontificale
Institutum Studiorum Orientalium, 1973.
Nikolaev S., “Spiritual Unity: The Role of Religious Authority in the Disputes
Between Sergii Bulgakov and Georges Florovsky Concerning Intercommunion,” St
Vladimir's Theological Quarterly, 49:1-2 (2005): 101-123.
Nikolaev S., “Church and Reunion in the Theology of Sergii Bulgakov and
Georges Florovsky, 1918-1940” (PhD dissertation, Southern Methodist University, 2007).
McGrath A. E., T. F. Torrance: An Intellectual Biography, London: T&T Clark,
1999.
Ramsey M. and D. Dales, Glory Descending: Michael Ramsey and His Writings,
Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2005.
Ramsbotham J., “Correspondence,” Journal of the Fellowship of St. Alban and St.
Sergius 21 (Sept 1933): 37-38.
Разумовский Г.А., “Протоиерей Георгий Флоровский, Из писем,” a а
1:48 (2007). Чланак је доступан и у елктронској верзији на адреси:
http://aliom.orthodoxy.ru/arch/048/flor48.htm. (приступљено 5. децембра 2012. године)
Архимандрит Софроний (Сахаров), Переписка с протоиереем Георгием
Флоровским, Свято-Иоанно-Предтеченский монастырь/Свято-Троицкaя Сергиевa
Лавра 2008.
Torrance T. F., “Our Oneness in Christ and Our Disunity as Churches,” in Conflict
and Agreement in the Church, vol. 1: Order and Disorder, London: Lutterworth Press,
1959, 332-45.
Torrance T. F., Theological Science, London: Oxford University Press, 1969.
Torrance T. F., Space, Time and Incarnation, London: Oxford University Press,
1969.
Torrance T. F., The Relevance of Orthodoxy, Stirling: Drummond Press, 1970.
Torrance T. F., “The Relation of the Incarnation to Space in Nicene Theology,” in:
Andrew Blane (ed.), The Ecumenical World of Orthodox Civilization: Russia and
Orthodoxy, vol. 3 (Essays in Honor of Georges Florovsky), Paris: Mouton, 1974. Рад је
прештампан у T.F. Torrance, Divine Meaning: Studies in Patristic Hermeneutics,
Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1995.
Torrance T. F., Theology in Reconstruction, Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1975.
Torrance T. F., Space, Time and Resurrection, Edinburgh: Handsel Press, 1976.
Torrance T. F., (ed.), Theological Dialogue Between Orthodox and Reformed
Churches, vol. 1, Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1985.
Torrance T. F., (ed.), Theological Dialogue Between Orthodox and Reformed
Churches, vol. 2, Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1993.
Torrance T. F., The Doctrine of Grace in the Apostolic Fathers, Eugene, Oregon:
Wipf & Stock, 1996.
Torrance T. F., The Christian Doctrine of God: One Being Three Persons,
Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1996.
Wirth J., The Conspiracy of Life: Meditations on Schelling and His Time, Albany,
N.Y.: State University of New York Press, 2003.
Theology According to Thomas F. Torrance,” Participatio 2 (2010): 5-43. Чланак је
доступан и у електронском облику на следећој адреси:
http://www.tftorrance.org/journal/participatio_vol_2_2010.pdf (приступљено 5. децембра
2012. године)
Baker M., “The Eternal ‘Spirit of the Son’: Barth, Florovsky and Torrance on the
Filioque,” International Journal of Systematic Theology 12:4 (2010): 382-403.
Baker M., “Georges Florovsky -- Agony of Divine and Human Freedom,” in: Er.
Conradie (ed.), Creation and Salvation: A Medley of Recent Theologies, Berlin: LIT Verlag
2012, 29-35.
Baker, M. “Cosmological Contingency and Logical Necessity in G. Florovsky and
T. Torrance," Orthodox Theology and the Sciences, ed. Pavel Pavlov, Stoyan Tanev and
George Dragas (Columbia, MO: New Rome Press, forthcoming.
Baillie D. and J. Marsh (eds.), Intercommunion, London: Student Christian
Movement, 1952.
Chaplits A., Cosmic Redemption and the Incarnation of Christ in the Writings of
Georges V. Florovsky and Thomas F. Torrance, M.A. Thesis, Trinity International
University, 2006.
Choufrine A. M., “Sergei Bulgakov: His Life and His Reflection on It: A Case
Study for the Churching of Russian Intelligentsia,” in N. A. Pecherskaya (ed.), The
Emancipation of Russian Christianity, Lewiston - Queenston – Lampeter, 1995, 1-16.
Chrysostomos of Etna, “Protopresbyter Georges Florovsky,” Orthodox Tradition
11:2 (1994): 28-29.
Congar Yves M.-J., Chretiens Desunis. Principes d'un "oecumenisme" catholique.
Unam Sanctam 1, Paris: Cerf, 1937.
Florovsky, G., “The Antinomies of Ecumenical Quest,” у; Georges Florovsky
Papers, Box 5, Folder 1; Department of Rare Books and Special Collections, Princeton
University Library.
Florovskij, G.V., “Náboženská zkušenost a filiofické vyznání,” Ruch filosoficky,
3:3:9-10 (1923), 298-306. Рад је објављен и на српском: Г. В. Флоровски, “Религиозно
искуство и филосовско исповедање”, Хришћански живот, 3:3 (1924): 105-118.
Florovsky G., “L’idée de la création dans la philosophie chrétienne,” Logos:
Revue Internationale de la Synthèse Orthodoxe 1 (1928): 3-30;
Флоровский Г. В., “Тварь и тварность,” Православная мысль 1 (1928), 176-212.
Florovsky, G., “The Limits of the Church,” Church Quarterly Review 117:233
(1933): 117-31.
Florovsky, G., “A Visit to Anglican Theological Colleges,” Journal of the
Fellowship of St. Alban and St. Sergius 21 (Sept 1933): 38-40.
Florovsky, G., “The Need for Patience,” Christendom 2:4 (1937): 556–559.
Florovsky, G., “The Idea of Creation in Christian Philosophy,” Eastern Churches
Quarterly 8:2 (1949): 53-77.
Florovsky, G., “The Legacy and the Task of Orthodox Theology,” Anglican
Theological Review 31:2 (1949): 65-71
Florovsky, G., “Une vue sur l’Assemblée d’Amsterdam,” Irénikon, 22.1 (1949): 5-25.
Florovsky, G., “Intercommunion: An Inter-‘Catholic’ Discussion,” The Student
World 43:2 (1950): 169-171.
Florovsky G., “The Doctrine of the Church and the Ecumenical Problem”, The
Ecumenical Review, 2:2 (Winter 1950): 152–161.
Florovsky, G., “Confessional Loyalty in the Ecumenical Movement,” The Student
World 53:1 (1950), 59-70.
Florovsky, G., “The Eastern Orthodox Church and the Ecumenical Movement,”
Theology Today, 7:1 (1950): 68-79.
Florovsky, G., “The Challenge of Disunity,” St Vladimir's Seminary Quarterly
3:1-2 (1954): 31-36.
Florovsky, G., “The Orthodox Churches and The Ecumenical Movement Prior to
1910,” in R. Rouse and S. C. Neill (eds.), A History of the Ecumenical Movement, 1517-
1948, Philadelphia: The Westminster Press 1954: 171-215.
Florovsky, G., “The Orthodox Church and the World Council of Churches,” St
Vladimir's Seminary Quarterly 2:4 (1954): 11-18, 12.
Florovsky, G., ”The Challenge of Disunity”, Union Seminary Quarterly Review
10:1 (Nov 1954): 15-20.
Florovsky, G., “The Predicament of the Christian Historian,” in: Walter Leibrecht
(ed.), Religion and Culture: Essays in Honor of Paul Tillich, New York: Harper &
Brothers, 1959: 140-166, 359-362.
Florovsky, G., “The Ethos of the Orthodox Church,” Ecumenical Review 12:2
(1960): 183-198.
Florovsky, G., “Primitive Tradition and the Traditions,” in W. S. Morris (ed.), The
Unity We Seek, Toronto: Ryerson Press, 1962: 28-38.
Florovsky, G., “Obedience and Witness,” in: R. Mackie and C. West (eds), The
Sufficiency of God: Essays in Honor of W. A. Visser’t Hooft, London: Student Christian
Movement Press, 1963: 58-70.
Florovsky, G., “The Problem of Ecumenical Encounter,” in E. J. B. Fry and A. H.
Armstrong (eds.), Re-Discovering Eastern Christendom, London: Darton, Longman &
Todd, 1963: 63-76.
Florovsky, G., “Interview with Georges Florovsky,” Concern 3:4 (Fall 1968): 9-
12, 27.
Florovsky, G., “Interview with Father G. Florovsky,” The Third Hour 9 (1970):
31-38.
Florovsky, G., Ways of Russian Theology, vol. II, Belmont, Mass.: Nordland Pub.
1987.
Fraser B., The Study of Religion in British Columbia, Waterloo, Ontario: Wilfrid
Laurier University Press 1995.
Gallaher B., “Bulgakov and intercommunion,” Sobornost 24:2 (2002): 9-28.
Irvine C., Worship, Church and Society: An Exposition of the Work of Arthur
Gabriel Hebert, Norwich: Canterbury Press, 1993.
Neiman. D and M. Schatkin (eds.), The Heritage of the Early Church: Essays in
Honor of George Florovsky, (Orientalia Christiana Analecta 195), Rome: Pontificale
Institutum Studiorum Orientalium, 1973.
Nikolaev S., “Spiritual Unity: The Role of Religious Authority in the Disputes
Between Sergii Bulgakov and Georges Florovsky Concerning Intercommunion,” St
Vladimir's Theological Quarterly, 49:1-2 (2005): 101-123.
Nikolaev S., “Church and Reunion in the Theology of Sergii Bulgakov and
Georges Florovsky, 1918-1940” (PhD dissertation, Southern Methodist University, 2007).
McGrath A. E., T. F. Torrance: An Intellectual Biography, London: T&T Clark,
1999.
Ramsey M. and D. Dales, Glory Descending: Michael Ramsey and His Writings,
Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2005.
Ramsbotham J., “Correspondence,” Journal of the Fellowship of St. Alban and St.
Sergius 21 (Sept 1933): 37-38.
Разумовский Г.А., “Протоиерей Георгий Флоровский, Из писем,” a а
1:48 (2007). Чланак је доступан и у елктронској верзији на адреси:
http://aliom.orthodoxy.ru/arch/048/flor48.htm. (приступљено 5. децембра 2012. године)
Архимандрит Софроний (Сахаров), Переписка с протоиереем Георгием
Флоровским, Свято-Иоанно-Предтеченский монастырь/Свято-Троицкaя Сергиевa
Лавра 2008.
Torrance T. F., “Our Oneness in Christ and Our Disunity as Churches,” in Conflict
and Agreement in the Church, vol. 1: Order and Disorder, London: Lutterworth Press,
1959, 332-45.
Torrance T. F., Theological Science, London: Oxford University Press, 1969.
Torrance T. F., Space, Time and Incarnation, London: Oxford University Press,
1969.
Torrance T. F., The Relevance of Orthodoxy, Stirling: Drummond Press, 1970.
Torrance T. F., “The Relation of the Incarnation to Space in Nicene Theology,” in:
Andrew Blane (ed.), The Ecumenical World of Orthodox Civilization: Russia and
Orthodoxy, vol. 3 (Essays in Honor of Georges Florovsky), Paris: Mouton, 1974. Рад је
прештампан у T.F. Torrance, Divine Meaning: Studies in Patristic Hermeneutics,
Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1995.
Torrance T. F., Theology in Reconstruction, Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1975.
Torrance T. F., Space, Time and Resurrection, Edinburgh: Handsel Press, 1976.
Torrance T. F., (ed.), Theological Dialogue Between Orthodox and Reformed
Churches, vol. 1, Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1985.
Torrance T. F., (ed.), Theological Dialogue Between Orthodox and Reformed
Churches, vol. 2, Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1993.
Torrance T. F., The Doctrine of Grace in the Apostolic Fathers, Eugene, Oregon:
Wipf & Stock, 1996.
Torrance T. F., The Christian Doctrine of God: One Being Three Persons,
Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1996.
Wirth J., The Conspiracy of Life: Meditations on Schelling and His Time, Albany,
N.Y.: State University of New York Press, 2003.
Published
2012-10-04
Section
Articles
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
a) Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
b) Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
c) Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
